Why Commercial Shotgun Shells Against Drones Make Sense Right Now

Why Commercial Shotgun Shells Against Drones Make Sense Right Now

A tiny buzz overhead used to mean a hobbyist filming a park. Today, that same sound can mean explosives diving straight at your squad.

When the U.S. Army Maneuver Battle Lab tested commercial shotgun shells against drones at Fort Benning, Georgia, it wasn't doing a quirky publicity stunt. Soldiers from Charlie Company, 1st Battalion, 29th Infantry Regiment ran live-fire shotshell trials at Bryant Range on September 21 and 22, 2026, firing four kinds of 12-gauge ammunition at 3D-printed target drones. One load was government-issued 12-gauge target ammunition meant for skeet and trap. The other three were commercial shotshells.

The core answer is simple. Frontline infantry need a fast, cheap, kinetic way to knock down small unmanned aircraft systems (sUAS) when electronic jammers fail, expensive missiles cost too much, or a single rifle bullet misses a zippy target.

Why the Army Looked at Commercial Shotgun Shells

Expensive air defense is a mismatch against a cheap quadcopter. Firing a six-figure missile at a drone that costs a few hundred or a few thousand dollars wrecks your cost exchange ratio fast.

Shotguns flip that math. A spread of pellets gives a shooter a wider cone of probability against a small, fast-moving airframe that jinks unpredictably. Even better, commercial off-the-shelf shells already exist in huge volumes on civilian shelves, which matters when supply chains are strained.

As Brian Dutton, a Maneuver Battle Lab contract project officer, put it during the assessment, drone warfare isn't an emerging threat anymore—it's already here. The Army isn't stopping at one shell either; leadership wants to see how future squads should be equipped and trained when drones show up over every patrol.

http://googleusercontent.com/lmdx_content/gcBpvWqyfclZWDMiGugoSvRwkhHqtbRrYVVIVvpltgYkLjLVkGIIbNKqJXXigpNhXVyjVdsGTdfYsGwoaFZjcGKCmAhvnNhGeyaQoFQOJll624479


How the Fort Benning Trials Actually Played Out

Forget sterile bench tests. Bryant Range put shooters through realistic flight profiles.

Target drones ran low and straight at the firing line. Others dove from 100 feet—about 30 meters—straight toward a soldier's position. Try tracking a diving aircraft while heart rate climbs and seconds tick away. It's hard.

Analysts from the Maneuver Battle Lab, the Maneuver Future Capability Directorate Lethality Team, and the Product Manager for Small Caliber Ammunition tracked real numbers:

  • How long it took a shooter to acquire, track, and hit the target.
  • How many shots were fired per engagement.
  • The exact distance where a hit actually stopped or disabled the drone.

Soldiers also watched pellet spread patterns to see how shot behaves at real engagement ranges. Master Sgt. Jonathan Gallogly pointed out why hands-on soldier touchpoints with experimental counter-sUAS ammo matter so much: troops have to feel how tough it is to lead a moving drone and learn the real envelope where a round can defeat it.

Rifles Came First for a Reason

Shotguns weren't tested in a vacuum. Before the September shotshell event, the Maneuver Battle Lab ran an August 18–19, 2026, rifle range to build a baseline.

Soldiers fired standard M855A1 enhanced performance ball ammunition alongside an experimental, specialized 5.56mm drone round using their standard M4 carbines. That sequence tells you how the Army is thinking. First, find out what your existing carbines and specialty rifle rounds can realistically do. Then test whether a 12-gauge scattergun gives you a better close-in shot when a drone closes fast.

If you've ever watched someone try to hit a fast clay target with a single-projectile rifle versus a shotgun, you already grasp the physics intuition. A rifle puts all its energy in one pinpoint path. A shotshell trades single-hole precision for a cloud of pellets, increasing the odds of clipping a rotor, battery, flight controller, or arm.

What Commercial Shotshells Get Right and Where They Fall Short

Let's be honest about limitations. A shotgun is not a magic wand.

First, range is tight. Shotgun pellets lose velocity and spread wide fast. Once a drone is far out, a 12-gauge load won't reach or won't carry enough energy to drop it cleanly.

Second, detection and reaction time still rule everything. As defense analyst and former infantry NCO Alain Servaes noted in his coverage of the trials, a shotgun gives a soldier an immediate option without needing a dedicated launcher or fire-control network—yet the soldier still has to spot the drone and react in a tiny window. If you don't see it until it's already on top of you, no shell saves you.

Third, the Army hasn't picked a winner yet. As of the November 20, 2026, public disclosures, the Army has not selected or fielded a new shotgun round from these trials. The exact commercial shell brands and shotgun models used haven't been publicly named, and the Maneuver Battle Lab plans to send its findings to capability and ammunition officials before the end of 2026.

That transparency matters. Testing is data collection, not a guaranteed procurement contract. Until the report lands and officials weigh cost, reliability, recoil, pattern density, and logistics, commercial shells remain an evaluated option rather than standard issue.

What This Means Beyond the Infantry Range

You don't need to wear a uniform to see why this matters. Commercial counter-drone hardware and tactics spill over fast.

Critical infrastructure teams, site security planners, and defense engineers are all wrestling with the exact same problem: small drones are cheap, plentiful, and hard to stop cleanly without collateral damage. Whether the Pentagon ends up buying commercial 12-gauge shells, specialized anti-drone cartridges, interceptor drones, or layered sensors, the mindset shift is locked in. Low-cost threats demand low-cost, adaptable counters.

If you're tracking defense procurement, counter-UAS tactics, or small-arms modernization, here are practical steps you can take right now:

  1. Read the official U.S. Army Maneuver Battle Lab release and DVIDS assessment coverage to track exact program terminology.
  2. Watch for the battle lab's end-of-2026 data submission to the MFCD Lethality Team and Product Manager for Small Caliber Ammunition to see whether commercial or government-standard loads get favored.
  3. Compare shotshell trials against rifle-round experiments (like 5.56mm drone ammunition) rather than treating shotguns as a standalone cure-all.
  4. Focus any security or training planning you do on early detection and target tracking first—because spotting a small drone early is half the fight.
VM

Valentina Martinez

Valentina Martinez approaches each story with intellectual curiosity and a commitment to fairness, earning the trust of readers and sources alike.